The Forecasting MachineRead report

Loading shared forecast

The Forecasting MachineOpen interactive report

Which party will win the 2026 US Senate election in Michigan?

The 2026 United States Senate election in Michigan will be held on November 3, 2026. The main candidates are Abdul El-Sayed (Democrat) and Mike Rogers (Republican).

Forecasted on

Resolved forecast

Status: Resolved

Outcome: Democrat

Resolved on

Resolution reasoning

NBC News projects Abdul El-Sayed (D) as the winner of the 2026 Michigan U.S. Senate race (results as of November 4, 2026); Wikipedia's 2026 U.S. Senate election results list the same outcome. Resolved on media projections ahead of official certification; to be corrected if the certified result differs.

Resolution criteria

Resolves to bin A (Democrat) if the Democratic Party candidate, Abdul El-Sayed (D), is certified as the winner; bin B (Republican) if the Republican Party candidate, Mike Rogers (R), is certified as the winner; bin C (Other) if an independent or other-party candidate is certified as the winner of the Michigan U.S. Senate seat contested on November 3, 2026. If the contest is not decided on election night — because of a runoff, a ranked-choice tabulation, or a recount — it resolves on the final certified result. Declared candidates: Abdul El-Sayed (D); Mike Rogers (R).

Historical forecast probabilities

  • Democrat: 75.8%
  • Republican: 23.7%
  • Other: 0.5%

Reasoning

The Democrat is favored, with a 75.8% chance of winning; the Republican has a 23.7% chance, and Other has a 0.5% chance. The race remains competitive, but late polling and the national environment favor Abdul El-Sayed, while Republican spending, late attacks, and the possibility of polling error keep Mike Rogers’s path open.

Democrat — 75.8%: A late polling shift, reinforced by the national climate

Michigan’s recent Senate history offers little reason to treat the state as safely belonging to either party: Rogers lost narrowly to Elissa Slotkin in 2024 even as Donald Trump carried Michigan [a3, a5, a7]. But the evidence closest to Election Day points more clearly toward El-Sayed than the spring picture did. While an early general-election poll showed Rogers ahead, 11 of 12 reported October polls put El-Sayed in front, generally by one to seven points. CNN had him up seven, and separate surveys from Glengariff, Marist, InsiderAdvantage, and Michigan State University/YouGov also showed leads; a Detroit News poll found him ahead in the Upper Peninsula as well [a9, e1497, e1499, e1502, e1529].

That pattern fits a national environment leaning Democratic. Democrats led the generic congressional ballot by eight points in a November 3 poll, while Trump’s approval stood at 32%; in Michigan, 59% disapproved of his job performance [e1687, e1532]. Consumer sentiment was also near a record low [e1692]. These conditions do not guarantee that voters will treat a Senate race as a referendum on the president, but they make the Democratic polling leads more plausible than if the national climate were neutral or Republican-leaning.

El-Sayed also had a substantial reported fundraising advantage: $47.7 million raised to Rogers’s $2.5 million in pre-election filings [e1530]. The campaign’s late surge after Haley Stevens endorsed Rogers suggests that the endorsement may have energized El-Sayed’s supporters rather than simply weakening him [e1683]. Prediction markets likewise favored El-Sayed, with Polymarket placing his chance of victory at about 70% [e1503]. Taken together, these signals support a Democratic advantage without making the race a foregone conclusion.

Republican — 23.7%: A close state, real late risks, and a costly campaign

Rogers’s strongest case begins with the state’s competitiveness. His near-miss in 2024 shows that a small shift in turnout or polling error can decide the seat [a3, a5, a7]. The October surveys mostly favored El-Sayed, but many showed narrow leads, and correlated polling errors could make a collection of polls look more decisive than it is.

Republicans also invested heavily. A Trump-linked group spent $18.5 million on Michigan advertising, and the Senate race became one of the cycle’s most expensive [e1686, e1474]. Rogers campaigned with prominent Republican allies, including JD Vance and Robert F. Kennedy Jr., while Republican-aligned ads and social-media claims targeted El-Sayed over his views and associations [e1408, e1410, e1470]. Late reporting of an undercover video involving an El-Sayed campaign volunteer added to those vulnerabilities [e1498]. The attacks may have limited persuasive power, but they could matter if they change even a small number of votes in a close contest.

There were also signs of potential Democratic coalition strain. Stevens’s endorsement of Rogers could appeal to some moderates, and early ballot returns showed more registered Republicans than Democrats among those who had returned ballots at that point [e1683, e1422]. Still, the early-vote comparison is not a representative snapshot of the final electorate: older voters were returning mail ballots at much higher rates than younger voters, which cautions against reading it as evidence of a broad Republican turnout advantage [e1419]. Betting odds moved somewhat toward Republicans late in October, another sign that the outcome was not settled [e1471].

Other — 0.5%: Possible, but not a realistic leading scenario

Michigan’s contest is centered on El-Sayed and Rogers, and the available evidence offers no basis for treating a third-party or independent candidate as a serious contender. Such a candidate could affect the major-party margin by drawing votes, especially in a close race, but winning outright would require an unexpected disruption to the basic two-party contest [e66].

Why these probabilities fit the evidence

The Democrat’s 75.8% probability reflects the strongest and most current evidence: a broad run of October polling leads, a Democratic-leaning national environment, and a major fundraising advantage. The Republican’s 23.7% probability preserves substantial room for Michigan’s close-state history, narrow poll leads, heavy GOP spending, and late campaign developments to matter. The 0.5% assigned to Other reflects the negligible chance of an upset by a third-party candidate. The picture is not one of certainty; it is a race in which the evidence has shifted toward El-Sayed, but not far enough to make a Republican win implausible.

Update summary

New reports indicate that El-Sayed raised $2.4 million in the day after Stevens endorsed Rogers, while some Muslim conference attendees said they still planned to support him despite policy disagreements [e1683] [e1685]. These are limited additions to an outlook that otherwise remains broadly unchanged.

Cited evidence