¿Abandonará Estados Unidos la OTAN durante el segundo mandato de Donald Trump?
El segundo mandato de Donald Trump como presidente de Estados Unidos comenzó el 20 de enero de 2025 y finalizará el 20 de enero de 2029. Se debe predecir si Estados Unidos abandonará la OTAN durante este período.
Forecasted on
Forecast probabilities
- Sí, Estados Unidos abandonará la OTAN.: 3%
- No, Estados Unidos no abandonará la OTAN.: 97%
Reasoning
La salida formal de Estados Unidos de la OTAN sigue siendo posible, pero muy improbable: Sí, 3.0%; No, 97.0%. La retórica de Trump y el deterioro de la confianza elevan el riesgo; la ley, la oposición del Congreso y la posibilidad de reducir el compromiso estadounidense sin abandonar el tratado pesan mucho más.
Sí: una ruptura que exigiría varios pasos improbables
Trump ha cuestionado repetidamente el valor de la alianza y ha amenazado con retirarse, con especial dureza tras la falta de apoyo aliado durante la guerra con Irán [a6, a17, e68, e712]. También podría intentar actuar sin autorización del Congreso y convertir la disputa en una batalla judicial [e16]. Las negociaciones sobre Ucrania ofrecen otro posible foco de crisis: Rusia ha vuelto a exigir que la OTAN reduzca su presencia en Europa oriental, y Zelenskyy dijo que los enviados estadounidenses plantearon intercambiar territorio del Donbás por la pertenencia de Ucrania a la alianza [e1739, e1743, e1746, e1740].
Eso hace que el riesgo no sea cero. Pero esos hechos apuntan sobre todo a una disputa sobre la política estadounidense y el despliegue de fuerzas, no a una salida formal de Estados Unidos. Para que esta ocurriera antes del fin del mandato, Trump tendría que superar la barrera legal y completar el procedimiento de retirada del tratado; hasta la fecha no se ha iniciado formalmente ese proceso.
No: las barreras institucionales y las alternativas a la salida
La ley de 2024, reforzada por la NDAA, prohíbe al presidente retirarse unilateralmente sin una ley del Congreso o el apoyo de dos tercios del Senado [a12, a13, a15, a31]. Más del 80% de los legisladores apoyan la pertenencia a la OTAN, y las elecciones de mitad de mandato de 2026 no produjeron un Congreso más dispuesto a autorizar la salida [a14, e1692]. La NDAA también muestra que el Congreso está reforzando los límites a la retirada unilateral de tropas, no despejando el camino para abandonar la alianza [a21].
El tiempo añade otra barrera: el Artículo 13 exige un año de preaviso, así que una notificación tendría que llegar aproximadamente a comienzos de 2028 para que la salida se hiciera efectiva antes del fin del mandato. La experiencia más cercana —Francia en 1966— consistió en dejar la estructura de mando integrada, pero seguir siendo miembro del tratado; esa clase de desvinculación parcial es más plausible que una salida formal [a17].
Y ya hay señales de esa diferencia entre debilitamiento práctico y abandono jurídico. Los aliados esperan una reducción de unos 5.000 soldados estadounidenses, bastante menor que los 25.000 que temían, mientras Washington ha frenado una rotación en Polonia y ha terminado un despliegue en Lituania [e1742, e1795, e853]. En cambio, Trump ha considerado establecer una base en Lituania [e1794]. Los aliados aumentaron el gasto y acordaron objetivos de defensa más altos, atendiendo una de las quejas más constantes del presidente [e809, e1789]. Las demandas rusas de revertir la presencia de la OTAN en Europa oriental han sido rechazadas por Finlandia y Alemania, que defendieron la pertenencia a la alianza y su papel como marco de seguridad europeo [e1750, e1754, e1796].
Por qué el 97% recae en “No”
La amenaza merece un 3%: Trump ha llevado su retórica más lejos que sus predecesores, y un intento unilateral podría desencadenar una crisis constitucional. Pero una salida efectiva requiere una cadena de acontecimientos improbable: una decisión formal, una disputa sobre la autoridad presidencial y la superación de una prohibición legislativa activa dentro de una ventana temporal limitada. Mientras tanto, la administración puede reducir la cooperación o las tropas sin abandonar el tratado, como ya sugieren los recortes y las tensiones en las estructuras de la OTAN. Esa separación entre la retórica de ruptura y la acción formal —junto con las barreras legales— justifica 3.0% para Sí y 97.0% para No.
Update summary
Las noticias de Abu Dabi reiteran propuestas ya conocidas sobre el Donbás y la arquitectura de seguridad europea. La expectativa de un recorte de tropas menor que el temido y las críticas de legisladores a la presión sobre Ucrania no cambian sustancialmente el panorama de una salida formal [e1742, e1762].
Cited evidence
- [a6] Trump Calls NATO Exit Final, Says 'Beyond Reconsideration' As Europe Reluctant To Support US in Iran War — ibtimes.sg • 2026-04-04T06:15:25.000Z
- [a17] What Would Happen if Trump Pulled Out of NATO? — Northeastern Global News • 2026-04-09T18:22:31.000Z
- [e68] President Donald Trump said he was weighing the possibility of withdrawing the United States from NATO during an interview with The Telegraph published on 1 April 2026 [2026-04-01] — 2026-04-01T12:23:41.000Z • Rating 5
- [e712] At the NATO Summit in Ankara (early July 2026), President Donald Trump said NATO allies "failed two key tests" and criticized the lack of international cooperation on the conflict with Iran [reported 2026-07-15] — 2026-07-15T22:56:56.000Z • Rating 4
- [e16] Former US House Speaker Nancy Pelosi posted on X that President Donald Trump cannot withdraw the US from NATO without congressional approval, calling his threats to leave “short-sighted” and a “gift to (Russian President) Vladimir Putin.” [2026-04-04] — 2026-04-05T10:53:31.000Z • Rating 4
- [e1739] US-brokered talks between Russia and other parties were held in Abu Dhabi on 10–11 November 2026, during which Moscow revived proposals first presented to the United States and NATO in December 2021, including demands for NATO to withdraw troops and military infrastructure from countries that joined the alliance after 1997. [2026-11-10 to 2026-11-11] — 2026-11-16T09:58:11.000Z • Rating 5
- [e1743] A confidential Russian briefing paper dated November 10, 2026, was circulated during negotiations in Abu Dhabi and demanded a rollback of NATO’s military presence in Eastern Europe to its 1997 level, an end to Western military aid to Ukraine, and the termination of NATO nuclear-sharing arrangements. [2026-11-10] — 2026-11-15T22:15:46.000Z • Rating 5
- [e1746] A Russian document dated November 10, 2026, was circulated during closed-door talks with American and Ukrainian delegations in Abu Dhabi; it called for NATO forces and infrastructure to withdraw to the alliance’s 1997 lines, an end to Western arms shipments to Ukraine, and no further NATO expansion. [2026-11-10] — 2026-11-15T01:48:55.000Z • Rating 5
- [e1740] Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy said on 14 November 2026 that US negotiators had raised the possibility of Ukraine withdrawing from the Ukrainian-controlled parts of Donbas in exchange for NATO membership; no formal proposal had been confirmed. [2026-11-14] — 2026-11-16T09:58:11.000Z • Rating 5
- [a12] A law from 2024 makes sure, Donald Trump can't pull the US from NATO without Congress — dagens.com • 2026-04-12T13:00:00.000Z
- [a13] US Lawmaker Warns Trump Against Unilateral NATO Withdrawal — latinamericasmallbusinessnews.com • 2026-07-01T00:54:13.000Z
- [a15] United States Lawmaker Warns Trump Against NATO Withdrawal Without Congress Approval — blogarama.com • 2026-04-09T00:00:00.000Z
- [a31] Trump NATO Exit Threat Legal Limits Article 13 Congress Approval Iran War — ibtimes.sg • 2026-04-02T07:42:34.000Z
- [a14] Congress blocks Trump from unilaterally withdrawing U.S. from NATO — global.espreso.tv • 2026-01-16T18:28:00.000Z
- [e1692] Democrats won the 2026 U.S. midterm elections, giving them a friendlier position in Congress toward Europe but not a veto-proof majority. [2026] — 2026-11-06T16:45:45.000Z • Rating 4
- [a21] US Congress Moves to Limit Trump's Ability to Withdraw Troops from Europe — us.headtopics.com • 2026-05-26T20:36:00.000Z
- [e1742] U.S. allies reportedly expect the Trump administration to reduce U.S. troop levels in Europe by about 5,000, rather than the previously feared 25,000, with most cuts coming from Germany and NATO’s eastern flank reinforced. [2026-11-15] — 2026-11-15T13:38:00.000Z • Rating 5
- [e1795] The Trump administration halted the planned deployment of a rotational Armored Brigade Combat Team to Poland, leaving one U.S. Army ABCT along NATO’s eastern flank for the first time since 2022. [2026-05] — 2026-11-16T20:34:31.000Z • Rating 4
- [e853] Washington recently ended the rotational deployment of more than 1,000 US troops in Lithuania without an immediate replacement (reported in 2026) [2026] — 2026-07-01T08:01:01.260Z • Rating 4
- [e1794] U.S. President Donald Trump said he would consider establishing a military base in Lithuania after Prime Minister Mindaugas Sinkevicius expressed willingness to facilitate the deployment of U.S. troops. [2026-10] — 2026-11-16T14:04:33.000Z • Rating 4
- [e809] The 30 European Nato members, together with Canada, increased their defence spending on average by 20% in 2026 (with a planned further 11% increase in 2027). [2026] — 2026-07-09T19:04:00.000Z • Rating 4
- [e1789] At a NATO summit in The Hague, member states agreed to raise defense and security-related spending to 5% of GDP by 2035. [2026-06] — 2026-11-11T11:12:05.000Z • Rating 4
- [e1750] Finnish Defence Minister Antti Häkkänen said Finland’s NATO membership cannot be negotiated after reports that Russian negotiators demanded Finland leave NATO during talks in Abu Dhabi on ending the war in Ukraine. [2026-11-13] — 2026-11-13T23:42:07.000Z • Rating 5
- [e1754] Finnish Defense Minister Antti Häkkänen rejected reported Russian demands for Finland to withdraw from NATO and for NATO military bases to leave the Baltic states; Kremlin spokesman Dmitry Peskov denied that Moscow had made or discussed a demand for Finland to leave NATO. [2026-11-13] — 2026-11-13T20:06:00.000Z • Rating 5
- [e1796] German Chancellor Friedrich Merz rejected renegotiating Europe’s security architecture, stating that NATO provides the established framework for European security. [2026-11-13] — 2026-11-13T15:04:00.000Z • Rating 4
- [e1762] Three senior Democratic lawmakers—Gregory Meeks, Adam Smith, and Jack Reed—issued a joint statement condemning Jared Kushner and Steve Witkoff for pressuring Ukraine to surrender territory, echoing Russian positions, and potentially weakening NATO. [2026-11-11] — 2026-11-12T02:44:38.000Z • Rating 5
- [e468] Marco Rubio's 2023 tweet saying 'No U.S. President should be able to withdraw from NATO without Senate approval' circulated widely on social media [2026-04-01] — 2026-04-01T19:11:00.000Z • Rating 4
- [e80] President Donald Trump repeatedly attacked NATO in 2026, calling the alliance a 'paper tiger' over its response to the Strait of Hormuz crisis, branding member states 'cowards,' and saying leaving the alliance was 'beyond reconsideration.' [2026] — 2026-04-06T09:27:36.000Z • Rating 4
- [e1765] NATO did not hold a defense ministers’ meeting in October 2026 as part of a broader reduction in high-level alliance meetings. [2026-10] — 2026-11-16T07:41:54.000Z • Rating 4
- [e1419] Elbridge Colby hosted two smaller “Bergen Group” meetings involving Norway, Sweden, Finland, Poland, Germany, and the Netherlands; Denmark could be added next. [2026-10-01] — 2026-10-01T04:26:29.000Z • Rating 4
- [e1759] The White House announced that Donald Trump will meet Vladimir Putin and Xi Jinping for their first dedicated trilateral meeting on the sidelines of a regional summit in Shenzhen, China, the following week. [2026-11-13] — 2026-11-14T01:58:00.000Z • Rating 5
- [a7] Trump calls for Spain's NATO suspension over Iran war stance — cryptobriefing.com • 2026-04-26T17:45:26.000Z
- [a10] Pentagon memo hints at US rethinking NATO support amid Iran war tensions — cryptobriefing.com • 2026-04-24T18:44:02.000Z
- [e1700] U.S. Ambassador to NATO Matthew Whitaker said at the Berlin Security Conference in Berlin that he did not expect U.S. foreign policy to change after the midterm elections. [2026-11-04] — 2026-11-04T10:30:05.000Z • Rating 4
- [a5] Trump Calls US-NATO Relationship "Ridiculous - Newsy Today — newsy-today.com • 2026-07-03T07:29:50.000Z
- [a8] NATO vows to defend Turkey amid Russian aggression, US exit seen as unlikely — cryptobriefing.com • 2026-04-23T00:52:41.000Z
- [a28] NATO chief signals improved US-Europe ties, reducing withdrawal likelihood — cryptobriefing.com • 2026-05-04T07:40:22.000Z
- [e1747] Russia reportedly demanded during peace negotiations that NATO withdraw its troops and bases from Poland and the Baltic states of Estonia, Latvia, and Lithuania; Finland rejected the demand. [2026-11-13] — 2026-11-14T12:18:47.000Z • Rating 5
- [e1799] Kremlin aide Yuri Ushakov announced plans for Vladimir Putin and Donald Trump to meet at the upcoming APEC summit. [2026-11-14] — 2026-11-14T10:12:11.000Z • Rating 4
- [e1801] EU defense ministers are scheduled to meet in Brussels with U.S. Under Secretary of Defense Elbridge Colby to discuss military support for Ukraine, transatlantic relations, and security challenges posed by China. [2026-11-17] — 2026-11-13T17:34:33.000Z • Rating 4
- [e1790] Rutte said European NATO allies and Canada were increasing defense investments by more than $250 billion over two years amid Russian aggression. [2026-11-11] — 2026-11-11T19:05:20.000Z • Rating 4
- [e1741] Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy said that U.S. peace envoys asked whether Ukraine would cede the Donbas region to Russia in exchange for NATO membership. [2026-11-15] — 2026-11-15T15:57:11.000Z • Rating 5
- [e1771] Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky said U.S. special envoys Steve Witkoff and Jared Kushner asked whether Ukraine would cede control of Donetsk and Luhansk in exchange for immediate NATO membership; Zelensky said this was the first time Washington had formally raised such a territorial exchange. [2026-11-14] — 2026-11-14T21:06:00.000Z • Rating 4
- [a3] NATO Records Record Defense Spending, NATO Secretary General Praises Trump Administration — voi.id • 2026-03-27T05:04:54.000Z
- [a4] Trump May Strip NATO Article 5 Over 5% Spending Rule - Bytes Europe — byteseu.com • 2026-03-28T15:54:33.000Z
- [e1758] President Donald Trump called in January for NATO member countries, though not necessarily the United States, to increase defense spending to 5% of gross domestic product. [2025-01] — 2026-11-11T19:03:25.000Z • Rating 5
- [e1756] U.S. special envoys Steve Witkoff and Jared Kushner were scheduled to meet Russian President Vladimir Putin in Moscow. [2026-11-12] — 2026-11-12T15:05:57.887Z • Rating 5
- [e1760] U.S. Special Envoy Steve Witkoff and Jared Kushner met Russian President Vladimir Putin in Moscow after two days of U.S.-mediated negotiations between Russian and Ukrainian representatives in Abu Dhabi. [2026-11-12] — 2026-11-12T00:00:00.000Z • Rating 5
- [e1804] Jared Kushner said the United States was preparing another round of trilateral peace talks involving Russia and Ukraine, while working to bring European partners directly into the process. [2026-11-14] — 2026-11-14T23:02:14.000Z • Rating 4